Oops! Giant Raptor’s Wishbone is Actually a Bit of Turtle Shell
Last November, palaeontologists announced the discovery of Dakotaraptor, a super-sized relative of Velociraptorsuper-sized relative of Velociraptor that stalked the Hell Creek Formation of North America alongside Tyrannosaurus rex. It was a formidable animal, 18 feet in length, with 9.5-inch sickle-shaped claws on its feet.
The dramatic beast was described by Robert DePalma from the Palm Beach Museum of Natural History, based on a incomplete skeleton that included parts of the backbone, arms, legs, and feet. But now, Victoria Arbour from the North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences has shown that one of Dakotaraptor’s bones—the wishbone, or furcula—isn’t what it seemed. It wasn’t even part of a dinosaur at all.
It was actually a piece of turtle shell.
Arbour and her colleagues noticed that the Dakotaraptor “wishbones” had features that aren’t seen in those of other meat-eating dinosaurs. Instead, they looked like they belonged to pancake turtles, which were common in the area where Dakotaraptor was found. The misidentified bones were probably the turtles’ entoplastra—part of the bottom halves of their shells, and the equivalent of collar-bones. It really is turtles all the way down.
“We stand corrected,” says David Burnham from the University of Kansas, who was involved in describing Dakotaraptor. It was an honest mistake: the dinosaur’s bones were surrounded by turtle remains, and one of the entoplastra was found under its arm.
“This is by no means an uncommon occurrence,” adds DePalma. Lucy, the iconic Australopithecus fossil discovered in 1974, had a misidentified baboon vertebrae in her spine for over 40 years before anyone spotted the error. And Utahraptor, an even bigger cousin of Dakotaraptor, was originally described together with the bone of a plant-eating dinosaur. “It happens more regularly than one might think, and we correct as needed—that’s how science works,” adds DePalma.
Indeed so. One wrong bone does not discredit the discovery of a truly impressive animal. Given the difficult nature of palaeontology, and the less-than-ideal condition of many fossils, it’s amazing that these errors don’t happen more often. And it’s always refreshing when scientists issue a swift mea culpa and correct things efficiently, as DePalma and Burnham have done, rather than spiralling into festering arguments.
Go Further
Animals
- These 'trash fish' are among Earth's most primitive animalsThese 'trash fish' are among Earth's most primitive animals
- These photos are works of art—and the artists are bugsThese photos are works of art—and the artists are bugs
- The epic migration of a 6-foot long, 200-pound catfishThe epic migration of a 6-foot long, 200-pound catfish
- Frans de Waal, biologist who studied animal emotion, dies at 75Frans de Waal, biologist who studied animal emotion, dies at 75
Environment
- Are synthetic diamonds really better for the planet? The answer isn't clear-cut.Are synthetic diamonds really better for the planet? The answer isn't clear-cut.
- This year's cherry blossom peak bloom was a warning signThis year's cherry blossom peak bloom was a warning sign
- The U.S. just announced an asbestos ban. What took so long?The U.S. just announced an asbestos ban. What took so long?
- The most dangerous job? Inside the world of underwater weldersThe most dangerous job? Inside the world of underwater welders
- The harrowing flight that wild whooping cranes make to surviveThe harrowing flight that wild whooping cranes make to survive
History & Culture
- Meet the powerful yokai that inspired the demon king in ‘Demon Slayer’Meet the powerful yokai that inspired the demon king in ‘Demon Slayer’
- A surprising must-wear for European monarchs? Weasels.A surprising must-wear for European monarchs? Weasels.
- Meet the woman who made Polaroid into a cultural iconMeet the woman who made Polaroid into a cultural icon
- Inside the observatory that birthed modern astrophysicsInside the observatory that birthed modern astrophysics
Science
- LED light treatments for skin are trendy—but do they actually work?LED light treatments for skin are trendy—but do they actually work?
- NASA smashed an asteroid. The debris could hit Mars.NASA smashed an asteroid. The debris could hit Mars.
- Humans really can have superpowers—scientists are studying themHumans really can have superpowers—scientists are studying them
- Why engineers are concerned about aging infrastructureWhy engineers are concerned about aging infrastructure
Travel
- Why you should try beach-hopping by boat around Paxos, GreeceWhy you should try beach-hopping by boat around Paxos, Greece
- Mansion museums show visitors the gritty side of the Gilded AgeMansion museums show visitors the gritty side of the Gilded Age
- 2024 will be huge for astrotourism—here’s how to plan your trip2024 will be huge for astrotourism—here’s how to plan your trip