You’d be forgiven for calling FTO the “fat gene.” There are two variants of the gene, and in study after study, one of those variants, known as rs993609, is associated with more weight, as well as a much higher risk of obesity. The comparison holds up in different countries, and in different ethnic groups. The link is so clear that it might seem like saying FTO can make you fat is as true as saying two plus two equals four.
Now try to imagine discovering that before World War II two plus two equaled zero.
That’s the gist of a new study on FTO’s effects over time. As I explain in my new “Matter” column for the New York Times, scientists have looked at the link between FTO and body-mass index in a long-term study of thousands of people over many decades. They found that people born before 1942 show no link. None. The link is strong in people born afterwards, and gets stronger with time.
I find this study interesting because it provides a twist on the old debate about nature versus nurture. Take two people with identical genes and put them in different environments, and some of their genes may respond in different ways. That’s long been a good counterargument against genetic hyper-determinism. Here’s a case where the entire environment–the world in which we live, work, and eat–has changed. As a result, a gene that would have gone overlooked if scientists looked for it a couple generations ago now leaps out as a clear factor in one of the world’s most pressing medical problems.
It’s possible that other genes will show patterns of their own over time. Putting a time axis on how genes affect our health may make studying the matter far more challenging–as well as using that information to guide medicine. What proves true now may not be true a few years from now.
PS– There’s a fascinating side-story about FTO that I didn’t have space to get into, which University of Chicago geneticist Vincent Lynch raised on Twitter. Ever since FTO’s effect was discovered in 2007, scientists have been puzzling over how that effect comes about. They’ve discovered that the FTO protein does all sorts of interesting things, including affecting the brain biochemistry involved in appetite. But a study that came out in March suggests the risk variant may have nothing to do with the FTO protein at all.
“Wha….?” you say? Well, here’s the thing. A gene like FTO is made up of two different kinds of pieces of DNA, called introns and exons. Cells make FTO proteins by only reading the exons of the FTO gene, essentially ignoring the introns. Packing genes with unread DNA may not sound smart, but evolution doesn’t build life the way you might.
It turns out that the rs993609 mutation sits in an intron in the FTO gene. So it doesn’t appear to change the FTO protein. Instead, scientists suspect that the rs993609 mutation sits in a little stretch of DNA in that intron, called an enhancer. They speculate that this enhancer can somehow coax our cells to make copies of another gene that lies elsewhere in our DNA. The rs993609 mutation changes how the enhancer acts on that other gene.
So rs993609 is “in” the FTO gene–in a geographical sense–and yet the FTO gene itself may not make post-war folks fat.
This molecular mystery doesn’t affect the patterns in the new study I wrote about in my column. But it will be important to understanding the biology of obesity. And it serves as a good lesson in how tricky it can be to talk about genes.
Go Further
Animals
- Octopuses have a lot of secrets. Can you guess 8 of them?
- Animals
- Feature
Octopuses have a lot of secrets. Can you guess 8 of them? - This biologist and her rescue dog help protect bears in the AndesThis biologist and her rescue dog help protect bears in the Andes
- An octopus invited this writer into her tank—and her secret worldAn octopus invited this writer into her tank—and her secret world
- Peace-loving bonobos are more aggressive than we thoughtPeace-loving bonobos are more aggressive than we thought
Environment
- Listen to 30 years of climate change transformed into haunting musicListen to 30 years of climate change transformed into haunting music
- This ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrificeThis ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrifice
- U.S. plans to clean its drinking water. What does that mean?U.S. plans to clean its drinking water. What does that mean?
- Food systems: supporting the triangle of food security, Video Story
- Paid Content
Food systems: supporting the triangle of food security - Will we ever solve the mystery of the Mima mounds?Will we ever solve the mystery of the Mima mounds?
History & Culture
- Strange clues in a Maya temple reveal a fiery political dramaStrange clues in a Maya temple reveal a fiery political drama
- How technology is revealing secrets in these ancient scrollsHow technology is revealing secrets in these ancient scrolls
- Pilgrimages aren’t just spiritual anymore. They’re a workout.Pilgrimages aren’t just spiritual anymore. They’re a workout.
- This ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrificeThis ancient society tried to stop El Niño—with child sacrifice
- This ancient cure was just revived in a lab. Does it work?This ancient cure was just revived in a lab. Does it work?
Science
- The unexpected health benefits of Ozempic and MounjaroThe unexpected health benefits of Ozempic and Mounjaro
- Do you have an inner monologue? Here’s what it reveals about you.Do you have an inner monologue? Here’s what it reveals about you.
- Jupiter’s volcanic moon Io has been erupting for billions of yearsJupiter’s volcanic moon Io has been erupting for billions of years
- This 80-foot-long sea monster was the killer whale of its timeThis 80-foot-long sea monster was the killer whale of its time
Travel
- How to plan an epic summer trip to a national parkHow to plan an epic summer trip to a national park
- This town is the Alps' first European Capital of CultureThis town is the Alps' first European Capital of Culture
- This royal city lies in the shadow of Kuala LumpurThis royal city lies in the shadow of Kuala Lumpur
- This author tells the story of crypto-trading Mongolian nomadsThis author tells the story of crypto-trading Mongolian nomads