National Geographic

United We Improve

Humans see further by standing on the shoulders of giants. We build upon the cultures, skills, technologies and knowledge of past generations, in a way that other animals do not.

Many scientists have suggested that this cumulative culture depends on the size of our groups. The more of us there are, the faster our culture ratchets upwards in complexity. If our populations shrink, we lose skills and tech. We see this in theoretical models. We see it in past civilisationsTasmania being the classic example.

And now, we can see it in two experiments. Working independently, two groups of scientists have shown that larger, more sociable groups are indeed better at maintaining complex cultural traditions, and even improving on them.

This might seem obvious, but people forget about it. As Joe Henrich, who led one of the new studies, told me, many scientists have assumed that Neanderthals were less intelligent than modern humans because they built less complex tools. The alternative is that they just lived in smaller, more scattered groups, and lacked the cultural ratchet that our ancestors had because of their big, connected societies.

As Henrich said: “For producing fancy tools and complexity, it’s better to be social than smart. And things that make us social are going to make us seem smarter.”

I’ve covered the two studies over at Nature News. Head over there for the details.

There are 3 Comments. Add Yours.

  1. AG
    November 14, 2013

    So, introverts have to be smarter to keep up with extroverts in a red queen style competion. But internet age certainly gives introverts unfair edge now since learning from others is no longer limited by social skill anymore.

  2. cw
    November 17, 2013

    Living in groups large enough to form useful traditions and following them is more successful than reinventing everything for yourself. Egad – that’s what conservatives believe!

  3. JLC
    November 17, 2013

    This offers a glimmer of a silver lining to the gloom we’re feeling as parents watching our children grow up glued to their digital devices. Perhaps there is a beneficial aspect to their apparent withdrawal into the virtual world if these devices multiply their reach as the local community expands to encompass greater numbers.

Add Your Comments

All fields required.

Related Posts