A Blog by

“Deaf” Frog Hears By Using Its Mouth As An Echo Chamber

Gardiner’s frog shouldn’t be able to hear. This dime-sized amphibian doesn’t have the right equipment for it.

In your head, sound waves pass through the flappy bits of your ear and vibrate a taut membrane—the eardrum. On the other side, three tiny bones transfer these faint air-borne vibrations into the fluid-filled inner ear, amplifying them along the way. In the inner ear, little hairs detect the vibrations and convert them into electrical signals that travel to your brain. This is how you hear, and it all depends upon the eardrum and the three bones within the so-called middle ear. Without these structures, 99.9 percent of the energy of incoming sound waves would be lost.

Gardiner’s frog doesn’t have a middle ear or an eardrum. It ought to be deaf.

And yet, it sings. When Renaud Boistel used loudspeakers to play recordings of the frog’s calls, other males would start calling in response. So, how does this “deaf” frog manage to hear? Boistel has a possible answer—they use their mouths.

A delightful chart showing some of the world's tiniest frogs, all doing jazz hands. Credit: Xiaphias
A delightful chart showing some of the world’s tiniest frogs, all doing jazz hands. Credit: Xiaphias

Gardiner’s frog is one of the smallest amphibians in the world. At its maximum size of 11 millimetres, it’s barely bigger than a fingernail. It’s part of a whole family of tiny frogs called sooglossids, found in the Seychelles Islands off the east coast of Africa. All of them lack middle ears, but all of them can apparently hear their own calls.

To find out how, Boistel’s team at the University of Paris-Sud analysed the frog’s skull with a very high-resolution X-ray scanner. This showed that the inner ear is completely surrounded by a capsule of bone, which might help to conduct incoming sound. But when they ran simulations of sound waves travelling through the frog’s skull, they found that these were still severely weakened by the time they reached the inner ear, despite the adjacent bone.

The simulations also ruled out another possible idea—that earless frogs might use their lungs to carry vibrations into their inner ears. That might be true for some species, but Gardiner’s frog has small lungs that don’t make good contact with its sides. They’d be terrible sound transmitters.

Gardiner's frog, viewed through X-ray holotomography. Credit: Renaud Boistel
Gardiner’s frog, viewed through X-ray holotomography. Credit: Renaud Boistel

But the team’s simulations also revealed something odd—a burst of pressure within the frog’s mouth. When the team added the animal’s mouth to their simulations, they found that it resonates at a frequency of 5,738 Hertz. Sounds of this frequency cause the mouth to reverberate strongly, turning it into an amplifier.

And guess what the average frequency of the frog’s call is? It’s 5,710 Hertz—roughly an F note, four octaves above middle C.

Gardiner’s frog seems to have a mouth that’s perfectly adapted for amplifying the calls of other Gardiner’s frogs, compensating for the lack of a middle ear. And it probably helps that the tissues between the mouth and inner ear are unusually thin.

This might explain why, in Boistel’s playback experiments, Gardiner’s frog reacts to the calls of its own kind, but not those of other frogs. Maybe its own calls are the only things it can hear.

“The idea is fascinating,” says Albert Feng from the University of Illinois. He proposed a similar idea back in 2011, to explain how another tiny frog, the Kihansi spray toad, could hear. However, Feng says the evidence that Boistel has provided is still tenuous and inconclusive, and he thinks they need to test their idea through experiments. For example, they might keep the frog’s mouth open, or briefly fill it with moistened cotton balls to see if they can still hear.

Reference: Boistel, Aubina, Cloeten, Peyrind, Scotti, Herzog, Gerlach, Pollet & Aubry. 2013. How minute sooglossid frogs hear without a middle ear. PNAS http://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1302218110

More on animal hearing:

8 thoughts on ““Deaf” Frog Hears By Using Its Mouth As An Echo Chamber

  1. Obviously its not the same frog, but it is still funny that a few other use their ears to sing. (Well their tymanic membranes to radiate sound.) You have to admit its a nice functional symmetry.

  2. Great article Mr. Young.
    I am sure this could have great implications in the study of deafness in humans and may lead to some interesting new treatments.

    However is it not true that humans can also “hear” through their mouths via vibrations on their teeth. I want to say I read or heard this somewhere. Also could it not be possible that their simulations did not include the right data about the bone surrounding the middle ear of the frog?

    I am curious as to this bone, I do not know much about frogs or ears, but most parts of the body have use there are some exceptions to this of course, but to me it would seem not very productive for evolution to isolate the inner ear of an animal with out serving a special purpose for said animal, especially knowing they can still hear. Maybe the bone acts much as the hair in our ears, but they just receive sound through their mouths? I don’t know just wondering if someone does. Again though this may have profound meaning in the study of human deafness and allow for some major advances in the area.

  3. Humans can indeed hear sound via their teeth, there is even a line of novelty toothbrushes that plays music this way (ostensibly too encourage kids to brush).

    1. Yeah I have seen those toothbrushes but I thought they were some kind of novelty. I want to say back in the late 90’s maybe the start of 2k I saw where people were having some sort of speaker implanted into their teeth or jaw bones. So I guess the novelty idea of the toothbrush was not so accurate. By novelty I mean that you could already hear them without putting in on your tooth and just being inside your mouth made it louder.

      I want to say that later in the 2k’s there was talk of implanting cell phones in your teeth.

  4. Very interesting article! I don’t know much about frogs or ears so it’s interesting to find out new facts about frogs. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *