National Geographic

A New Culprit in China’s Tainted Milk Saga: Gut Bacteria

Wei Jia became a professor at The University of North Carolina at Greensboro in August of 2008, after 10 years working at the Shanghai Jiao Tong University. He is a specialist in metabolomics, meaning that he looks at the chemical byproducts, or metabolites, of cells, tissues and living things. He’s done chemical analyses of the blood of colorectal cancer patients, for example, and of the amniotic fluid of malnourished pregnant rats.

Just a month after Jia moved to the U.S., he and the rest of the world heard about a tragedy in his native country. Thousands of babies in China were sick with kidney stones and several had died after drinking formula laced with a ubiquitous and cheap industrial chemical called melamine.

dairy-flyer

Cory Doctorow

This was no accident, nor the result of naive incompetence. Dairy companies — nearly two dozen of them — had intentionally added melamine to the milk powder. The manufacturers knew melamine would artificially boost the protein content of the formula, even though the chemical can’t be digested. They thought it was harmless. And they were horribly wrong. Over the next few months, 300,000 children got sick and six died.

As soon as Jia found out, he called his old team of collaborators in Shanghai to start investigating this scientific head-scratcher: Why was melamine so toxic? “Because it’s not, really. It’s not supposed to be absorbable by the human body,” Jia says. Its LD-50 (“lethal dose-50″), or the dose at which 50 percent of those exposed would die, is 3161 mg/kg in rats, an incredibly low toxicity. So why had so many children gotten sick?

Jia’s team turned to studies done on melamine poisoning in pets, research triggered by another Chinese food scandal. Manufacturers in China had long been adding grain containing ground-up melamine to pet food and other animal feed as a cheap filler, and these products were sold in the United States and elsewhere. This came to light in Asia in 2004 and in the U.S. in 2007, when melamine killed 16 dogs and cats in the U.S. and made thousands of others sick. Some 60 million packages of pet food were recalled.

Scientists from the University of Georgia analyzed blood and tissue samples from cats and dogs that had died from the contaminated food. Kidney tissue from all of the animals contained not only melamine, but a chemical called cyanuric acid, which is a common by-product in the manufacturing of melamine, the study found. Jia’s team reported similar results in 2009. They gave rats melamine, cyanuric acid, or a mix of both, and found that tiny doses of melamine could lead to kidney failure, but only when paired with cyanuric acid. It turns out that together, melamine and cyanuric acid form crystals in the kidney that turn into dangerous kidney stones.

According to Jia, many researchers had assumed that the cyanuric acid had come from the pet food, just like melamine. But he suspected otherwise. He knew that in the environment, soil microbes in the Klebsiella family could interact with melamine to produce cyanuric acid. What if the same thing was happening in the gut of the sick pets and babies?

His rat study had shown that when the animals were given high doses of melamine alone, their urine contained a chemical signature — low phenylacetylglycine paired with high trimethylamine-N-oxide and 3-phenylpropionate, for the metabolomic geeks out there — that pointed to the metabolism of gut microbes. But that didn’t prove that microbes had anything to do with the poisoning.

In a new study, published today in Science Translational Medicine, Jia presents much stronger evidence for the idea that gut bacteria spur melamine to make cyanuric acid, leading to trouble.

The researchers first gave rats high doses of melamine paired with an antibiotic. The figure below shows the animals’ kidney cells. Rats exposed to melamine alone (right panel) developed some of the dreaded melamine-cyanuric acid crystals (see red arrow). But rats given the antibiotic (left panel) showed no crystals.

Kidney cells exposed to melamine and antibiotics (left) versus melanine alone (right). White arrows show mild hemorrhaging; red arrows show crystals, which turn into dangerous kidney stones. From Zheng et al., Science Translational Medicine 2013

In other experiments, the researchers mixed melamine with fecal samples taken from the rats. Cyanuric acid appeared after 24 hours, but didn’t show up at all in control mixtures without the fecal matter. Then, to narrow down what kind of bacteria might be responsible, the scientists performed a DNA analysis of the rat poop. They found seven species of Klebsiella, including one, called K. terrigena, which had been previously shown to convert melamine to cyanuric acid.

Finally, putting everything together, the researchers colonized the guts of rats with K. terrigena (by feeding a lot of it to them over four days). Kidney cells in these colonized rats were chock full of crystals, hemorrhaging and inflammation:

Zheng et al., Science Translational Medicine 2013

Zheng et al., Science Translational Medicine 2013

So, are gut microbes definitely the reason that the tainted milk made some kids sick? Not necessarily, Jia says, but it’s a strong possibility.

This type of bacteria is not a normal resident of the human gut. That might explain why the overwhelming majority of babies who were exposed to the tainted milk actually didn’t get sick.

So how would some of the kids (and pets) have picked up Klebsiella? Jia says that science can’t say for sure. But he notes that the babies who got sick tended to be from the countryside, rather than cities. “You could imagine that these kids, from relatively poor families, were exposed to a lot of dirt and soil, and may be more susceptible to having this type of bacteria,” he says.

Whether or not these gut microbes turn out to be the biological culprit in melamine poisoning, the data provide yet another example of the many ways that the bacteria that live on us, the so-called microbiome, can affect what we eat and how we live. The microbiome “can explain more and more problems that we were not able to explain in the past,” Jia says. “In the future, for toxicity and pharmacological studies, we need to redesign experiments to take this into consideration.”

In thinking about these possible microbial culprits, let’s not forget about the far more culpable human ones. In January of 2009, Chinese officials tried and sentenced 19 people who worked for the dairy manufacturers and knew about the melamine contamination: 15 went to jail for 2 to 15 years, 3 were imprisoned for life, and 1 received a suspended death sentence. In November of that year, two others were executed.

Just last month, meanwhile, grocery stores in Australia reported that baby formula is flying off their shelves, apparently because of a surge of demand from Chinese parents afraid to buy it in their own country.

*

Top photo by Jon Feinstein, Kowloon flyer by Cory Doctorow, both via Flickr

There are 6 Comments. Add Yours.

  1. Erica Mitrano
    February 13, 2013

    Interesting story. But there’s an error in paragraph three: Melamine is not a protein, so it can’t “boost the protein content.” Instead, it was used to boost the nitrogen content, where nitrogen tests were used as a quick-and-dirty surrogate for protein tests.

    • Virginia Hughes
      February 13, 2013

      Hi Erica,

      Thanks for reading. You’re right, and thanks for pointing it out here. I just didn’t feel like that extra detail was necessary in the text, so I wrote “artificially boost” as a shortcut. Cheers

  2. Isabel de Castro
    February 14, 2013

    I like the story. You’ve summarized the findings perfectly. I am going to follow your blog because I like the way you write.

  3. Martyn Cornell
    February 15, 2013

    It’s not just in Australia that mainland Chinese buy baby formula because they don’t trust their own manufacturers. In Hong Kong, buyers are now restricted to two timns of baby milk at a time, because mainlanders were buying it in vast quantities and taking it back across the border.

  4. volannteer
    February 20, 2013

    The Chinese additives killed my cat in 2007. I still miss her, still feel angry for her suffering and death. I can’t imagine how I would feel if my baby had died because of ignorance and greed. It is good to know parents are taking necessary precautions to take care of their babies. I suggest they keep them away from lead paint too. That means toys and jewelry. My pets no longer get the brand of food (Eucanuba) which poisoned my cat and I no longer buy things manufactured in China. Brother, that is one difficult goal!

  5. Lindum
    March 29, 2013

    The companies that introduced the melamine did so because they knew that it masked the protein tests, enabling them to cheat by watering down the milk. As to whether they knew it was harmful: they didn’t care. This is a typical cultural attitude found in Asia and especially in China – if it’s not harming my family – why do I care? The Chinese will put anything in food in the name of profit. By the way, even when they found out it was damaging children – they still continued to do it.

Add Your Comments

All fields required.

Related Posts